RTBM.NET

Location: Old Hamilton County Jail - April 2025

The Old Hamilton County Jail is a creepy historical jail located in Florida, with a questionable past:

Location and Appearance:

The Old Hamilton County Jail in Jasper, FL, is a historic 1893 building with unique architecture, including a distinctive clock tower. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, it is now the Hamilton County Historical Museum after serving as a jail and witnessing significant local events.

The site is situated at 501 Northeast 1st Avenue, Jasper, Florida.

Historical Significance:

The Old Hamilton County Jail in Jasper, Florida, is the oldest surviving jail structure in the state and a rare example of a nineteenth-century county-owned facility. Built in 1893, it represents the early history of Hamilton County and showcases the work of the renowned P.J. Pauly & Brother Jail Company. The jail served as a community landmark for almost a century, housing the local sheriff's family and playing a role in significant local events. Today, it stands as a historical museum, offering a glimpse into the county's past.

Additional Sources

Silent Slayer tours - Our tour guides for the trip

Hamilton County - The official Hamilton County website, with historical data on the jail

Southern Spirit Guide - A Spirit hunters point of view

An Unforgettable Night at the Old Hamilton County Jail: A Journey Through Time and Terror

Our journey began at the historic Old Hamilton County Jail in Jasper, Florida—a foreboding structure built in 1893. The jail's brick, steel, and concrete exterior gave way to an interior that was both intriguing and unsettling. The building served not only as a prison but also as the sheriff's residence, with the family's kitchen separated from the jail due to fire hazards.

As we explored the dimly lit halls, we couldn't help but feel a sense of dread and isolation that must have been all too familiar to the inmates who once called this place home. The cold, dark cells were a stark reminder of the despair and loneliness experienced by those imprisoned within these walls. The knowledge that this was the site of the last three legal hangings east of the Mississippi River—an event that drew crowds of spectators—only intensified the somber atmosphere.

Our group, led by the knowledgeable team from Silent Slayer Ghost Tours, ventured deeper into the jail's ominous recesses. We felt an immediate connection to the eerie ambiance of the place, which was further accentuated by faux scary props staged throughout the building for Halloween attractions.

Throughout the night, we encountered numerous inexplicable phenomena that left us questioning our own senses. In one instance, we were drawn to the smaller women's cell, which exuded an oppressive, dark feeling, as if something—or someone—still lingered there. Later, in the larger women's cell, we engaged in a haunting "conversation" with a female spirit using a REM pod device. The spirit appeared to have a strong attachment to the cell, and it seemed to respond to my wife's questions, while ignoring my own inquiries.

Our investigations using spirit boxes, EMF meters, and other tools provided some intriguing results but no concrete evidence. We conducted numerous sessions in various parts of the jail, including its most sinister corners. At one point, three EVP meters triggered simultaneously in the downstairs area, leaving us to speculate about the unseen force that had caused the disturbance.

As we continued our exploration, a chill ran down our spines when we witnessed a dark, fleeting figure—a "shadow crawler"—darting across the room. While we attempted to communicate with the enigmatic presence, it remained elusive, leaving us eager to delve even deeper into the mysteries of the Old Hamilton County Jail.

Our night at this chilling historical site was an unforgettable experience that left us with a newfound appreciation for the history and mysteries that linger within its walls. As we departed, we couldn't shake the feeling that we had connected with the spirits of the past and become part of the ongoing story of this hauntingly historic landmark.